It’s Coming for You! could well be the headline of many technological articles we’ve read in the past year or so. The “it” is Artificial Intelligence. Computer-directed robots have long been major parts of the factory assembly line, but the work of white-collar workers and researchers is increasingly being taken over by AI. Nowadays, even professional analysts and technical writers are uneasily looking over their shoulders. Art appraisers are not immune to this worry. At the recent annual conference of the Appraisers Association of America, more than one panel was devoted to the use and abuse of AI in our field. The most dystopian nightmare is that a program would be invented that would enable a anyone to place an accurate value on a work of art. In some ways, the idea doesn’t seem that far-fetched. An AI program such as ChatGPT could be fed information about buyer preferences that appraisers have long known. For example, paintings with nudes are harder to sell than paintings of clothed people. A painting of a cute puppy will attract more buyers than a painting of raccoon roadkill. A portrait of a famous person will fetch a higher price than a portrait of a provincial banker. A painting with a subject that is atypical for a particular artist will not find as many buyers as one of his or her “trademark” pieces does. And so on. In theory, you could photograph a painting and input the image with the painting’s dimensions, its medium, its date, and so forth, into the program. AI would search its database of auction prices, adjust for size, desirability,...